Engineering

Microservices vs the majestic monolith: which fits your scale?

Most startups and growing products should start with a well-structured monolith: one codebase, one deployment, clear internal modules.

Sarvesh Pathak

Head of AI Development

Published

2 min read

0:00 / 0:00

Short answer: Most startups and growing products should start with a well-structured monolith: one codebase, one deployment, clear internal modules. Move to microservices only when a specific part needs to scale or ship on its own schedule, or when several teams keep blocking each other. Splitting too early adds cost and complexity without solving a real problem.

Few architecture debates last as long as this one. Microservices promise independent scaling and independent teams. Monoliths promise simplicity. Both are right, at different stages.

What each option actually means

• Monolith: the whole application is one codebase, deployed as one unit. A "majestic" monolith is a well-organised one, with clean modules inside, not a tangle.

• Microservices: the application is split into small services, each with its own codebase, data and deployment, talking to each other over the network.

When a monolith is the right call

• One team, or a few small teams. Everyone can understand the whole system.

• The product is still changing fast. Moving a boundary inside one codebase is a refactor. Moving it between services is a project.

• Traffic is moderate or predictable. One well-tuned application on a few servers handles more than most teams expect.

• You need to ship this quarter. One pipeline, one set of logs and one place to debug.

When microservices earn their cost

• One part has very different load. Search, notifications or payments may need to scale on their own.

• Teams block each other. If releases wait on unrelated changes from other teams, separate services can untangle them.

• Parts need different technology or compliance rules. A payment service may need stricter controls than a content service.

• You already have the operations maturity. Monitoring, tracing, automated deployment and on-call for many services are not optional.

The hidden costs of splitting early

• Network calls fail in ways function calls don't

• Data spread across services makes reporting and consistency harder

• Every service needs its own pipeline, monitoring and security review

• Debugging one user's problem can mean tracing it through several services

Comparison

 

Well-built monolith

Microservices

Speed to first release

Fast

Slower

Running cost and operations

Low

Higher

Scaling one part on its own

Limited

Strong

Teams shipping independently

Harder as teams grow

Strong

Debugging

Simpler

Harder

Best for

Startups, single teams, fast-changing products

Large teams, uneven load, strict domain boundaries

Our default

We usually start clients on a modular monolith with clear internal boundaries. When one module genuinely needs its own scaling or release schedule, it can be pulled out as a service without a rewrite. Most products never need more than a handful of services, and many never need any.

FAQ

Are microservices better for scalability?

They let you scale individual parts separately, which helps when load is uneven. For most products, a well-built monolith scales further than expected at a much lower cost.

When should we split our monolith?

When a specific module needs its own scaling, release schedule or compliance boundary, or when teams consistently block each other. Split that module, not the whole system.

Can we move from a monolith to microservices later?

Yes, if the monolith has clean internal modules. Each module can be extracted one at a time while the rest keeps running.

About the author

Sarvesh PathakSarvesh Pathak

Head of AI Development

Sarvesh Pathak leads AI development at Incredible Visibility, where he is the architect behind Mayavi and SCAI, SandCloud's AI platform. He has been building software since 2014.

More from Sarvesh →
Engineering

Share this article

Keep exploring

More perspectives

All insights →
Incredible Visibility Logo

Let's build something that lasts.

Whether you're launching a new product, modernizing a platform, or scaling your engineering organization — we bring the experience, depth, and clarity to help you move forward confidently.